Weil-McLain logo

    Weil-McLain

    premium
    4.9
    Burnham logo

    Burnham

    premium
    4.85

    Weil-McLain vs Burnham

    Expert head-to-head boiler comparison by Nassau County installers.

    Head-to-Head Scorecard

    3

    Weil-McLain

    3 wins

    1 tie
    1

    Burnham

    1 win

    Draw
    ⚡Efficiency
    Draw
    Winner
    🛡️Reliability
    💰Price
    Winner
    Winner
    📋Warranty
    Winner
    🔧Dealers

    Weil-McLain leads overall

    Performance Score Rings

    Weil-McLain
    Burnham
    4.9
    Rating
    Rating◀ WINS
    4.85
    Rating
    95%
    AFUE Max
    AFUE MaxTIE
    95%
    AFUE Max
    3
    Boiler Types
    Boiler TypesTIE
    3
    Boiler Types
    Weil-McLain logo

    Weil-McLain

    premium
    Rating
    4.9/5
    AFUE Max
    95%
    Price
    $4.5k – $12.0k
    Parts Warranty
    2 years

    Top Strengths

    • Industry leader in cast iron steam boilers since 1881
    • Lifetime heat exchanger warranty on all cast iron models
    • Same-day parts from F.W. Webb in Hicksville and Farmingdale

    Watch Out For

    • Higher upfront cost than Korean and Chinese competitors
    • Cast iron units may require crane for tight basement access
    Burnham logo

    Burnham

    premium
    Rating
    4.85/5
    AFUE Max
    95%
    Price
    $4.0k – $11.0k
    Parts Warranty
    2 years

    Top Strengths

    • America's oldest boiler manufacturer - trusted since 1873
    • Same-day parts availability at F.W. Webb and local supply houses
    • Alpine series qualifies for PSEG Long Island rebates up to $1,000

    Watch Out For

    • Electronics in Alpine series sensitive to Long Island power surges
    • Condensing models require condensate neutralizer installation

    ←Swipe to compare→

    Expert Verdict

    Weil-McLain wins for most Long Island homes. Superior cast iron quality, better warranty, and the strongest dealer network in Nassau County.

    Pick Weil-McLain when…

    You want the gold standard in cast iron boilers with the best heat exchanger warranty and widest local service network.

    Full Weil-McLain review

    Pick Burnham when…

    You want a reliable budget-friendly cast iron boiler — Burnham offers solid performance at 10-15% lower pricing.

    Full Burnham review

    Category-by-Category Breakdown

    Click any category to see why one brand wins.

    Full Specification Comparison

    Spec Weil-McLain Burnham
    Overall Rating
    4.9/5
    4.85/5
    Price Range (Installed)
    $4.5k – $12.0k
    $4.0k – $11.0k
    AFUE Range
    84–95%
    82–95%
    Parts Warranty
    2 years
    2 years
    Heat Exchanger Warranty
    Lifetime (cast iron)
    Lifetime (cast iron) / 20 years (stainless)
    Founded
    1881
    1873
    Country
    USA
    USA
    Parent Company
    Marley-Wylain
    US Boiler Company

    Warranty Comparison Timeline

    Weil-McLain
    Burnham
    0yr5yr10yr15yr20yr25yr
    Parts Warranty
    2 years
    2 years
    Heat Exchanger
    Lifetime (cast iron)
    Lifetime (cast iron) / 20 years (stainless)

    * All warranties shown assume product registration. Unregistered units typically receive 5-year coverage.

    Visual Comparison

    Weil-McLain
    Burnham
    Overall Rating
    4.9/5vs4.85/5
    AFUE Max
    95%vs95%
    Boiler Types
    3 typesvs3 types

    Pros & Cons

    Weil-McLain

    Strengths

    • Industry leader in cast iron steam boilers since 1881
    • Lifetime heat exchanger warranty on all cast iron models
    • Same-day parts from F.W. Webb in Hicksville and Farmingdale
    • Proven 143+ year track record in American homes
    • Ultra Series 3 & 4 qualify for PSEG Long Island rebates up to $1,000

    Weaknesses

    • Higher upfront cost than Korean and Chinese competitors
    • Cast iron units may require crane for tight basement access
    • Annual maintenance essential for coastal Long Beach and Island Park homes
    • No combi boiler options - separate water heater required

    Burnham

    Strengths

    • America's oldest boiler manufacturer - trusted since 1873
    • Same-day parts availability at F.W. Webb and local supply houses
    • Alpine series qualifies for PSEG Long Island rebates up to $1,000
    • Popular throughout Levittown, Massapequa, and Hicksville
    • Excellent hot water consistency for multi-zone baseboard systems

    Weaknesses

    • Electronics in Alpine series sensitive to Long Island power surges
    • Condensing models require condensate neutralizer installation
    • Some mid-range models have shorter 10-year warranties
    • Stainless heat exchangers require annual inspection in hard water areas

    Need Help Choosing Between Weil-McLain and Burnham?

    We install and service both brands. Get a free, no-pressure quote.

    Long Island Installation Guide

    Long Island Installation Guide

    Both brands are workhorses in Long Island's hydronic heating market. Weil-McLain dominates older Nassau County homes with radiant heat. Parts for both are readily available through F.W. Webb and local distributors.

    Climate Zone 4A

    Coastal Salt Air

    PSEG Rebates

    Customer Reviews

    ❓Weil-McLain vs Burnham FAQ

    Is Weil-McLain or Burnham better for Long Island homes?

    Weil-McLain wins for most Long Island homes. Superior cast iron quality, better warranty, and the strongest dealer network in Nassau County.

    Which is cheaper to install in Nassau County, Weil-McLain or Burnham?

    Weil-McLain ranges from $4.5k – $12.0k installed, while Burnham ranges from $4.0k – $11.0k installed in Nassau County.

    Are Weil-McLain and Burnham made by the same company?

    No. Weil-McLain is made by Marley-Wylain, while Burnham is made by US Boiler Company.

    What warranty does Weil-McLain offer vs Burnham?

    Weil-McLain offers 2 years parts warranty and Lifetime (cast iron) heat exchanger warranty. Burnham offers 2 years parts warranty and Lifetime (cast iron) / 20 years (stainless) heat exchanger warranty.

    Still Deciding?

    Get a free, personalized recommendation based on your home.