Long Island, NY

    Considering American Water Heaters water heaters for a Long Island home?

    • Exact brand and model fit confirmed before proposal
    • Warranty and current incentive terms reviewed in writing
    • 5.0 Google rating · 122 reviews
    Compare the installation process first? Read our water heaters installation guide →
    American Water Heaters logo
    #24 Water Heater BrandValue

    American Water Heaters Water Heaters Review 2026

    Best basic replacement option

    3.8/5• Expert Rating

    UEF Range

    0.65–0.7

    Types

    1

    $

    Price Range

    $

    Tank Warranty

    6 years

    Origin

    USA

    Why American Water Heaters?

    Best basic replacement option. Trusted by Nassau County homeowners since 1874.

    Part of A.O. Smith Corporation

    Best For:Best basic replacement option
    Types:Tank
    Warranty:6 years tank
    Share

    Is American Water Heaters water heater any good?

    Yes — American Water Heaters water heaters are a strong value pick. Our editorial score is 3.8/5 based on published efficiency, climate fit, warranty, features, and price positioning. American Water Heaters is associated with A.O. Smith Corporation; confirm the exact model platform, parts path, and coverage rather than assuming they are shared. For a Long Island home, compare the exact matched system and written installation scope because design and commissioning can matter as much as the badge on the equipment.

    Our Review Process

    Ratings are editorial comparison scores—not customer reviews, installation counts, or manufacturer endorsements.

    American Water Heaters Water Heater Planning for Nassau County and Suffolk County

    A useful American Water Heaters comparison starts with the exact indoor and outdoor model pairing—not the brand name alone. Home+ Air & Heat can review American Water Heaters water heater options for homes in our covered Nassau County, Suffolk County and the five NYC boroughs service areas, then document whether the proposed equipment, capacity, electrical scope, and installation approach fit the project.

    Before work is authorized, ask for the design method, AHRI match where applicable, installer or dealer qualification required by the manufacturer, registration responsibility, parts coverage, labor coverage, exclusions, and current incentive assumptions in writing. Those details vary by model, project, contractor status, installation date, and current program rules.

    Nassau County & W. SuffolkBrand & Model Fit VerifiedScope & Coverage in Writing

    American Water Heaters Water Heater Reviews: Our Installer Assessment

    American Water Heaters rates 3.8 out of 5 in our value-tier water heater assessment. The scoring reflects build quality, parts availability on Long Island, warranty terms, and how the equipment holds up in the homes we service. Best for: Best basic replacement option. Reviews are only half the picture — sizing and installation quality drive most of the failures we get called to.

    This is Home+ Air & Heat's own editorial assessment as an insured, EPA 608-certified installing contractor, not an average of customer star ratings.

    What reviewers and installers praise

    • • A.O. Smith family quality
    • • Very affordable
    • • Basic reliable heating
    • • Widely available

    Complaints worth knowing before you buy

    • • Tank only
    • • Basic features
    • • Shorter warranty
    • • No premium options

    How to judge a American Water Heaters quote

    • • Ask for the exact model numbers and the load calculation behind the sizing.
    • • Confirm who registers the warranty and what labor coverage is included, in writing.
    • • Check that the installer is qualified for the specific line, not just the brand.
    • • Compare total installed scope — venting and electrical — not just equipment price.

    Expert Review: American Water Heaters

    First-hand experience from our Nassau County water heater installation team.

    Our Field Experience with American Water Heaters in Nassau County

    Here at Home+ Air & Heat, we’ve been installing water heaters in Jericho, Nassau County, and across Long Island for years. American Water Heaters are a brand we’re quite familiar with, primarily because of their strong presence in the value segment. When homeowners are looking for a straightforward, affordable water heating solution, American often comes into the discussion. We've found them to be reliable workhorses, particularly for those on a tighter budget, and their widespread availability makes sourcing parts and units relatively easy.

    Our installation team has consistent experiences with American Water Heaters. The installations are generally uncomplicated, and the units fit well into standard residential setups. We appreciate that, as a brand under the A.O. Smith Corporation, they inherit some of that reputable engineering and manufacturing quality. This translates to fewer issues right out of the box, which is always a plus for both us and our customers. We’ve seen them perform consistently in homes across Nassau County, from older village homes to newer suburban developments.

    Handling Long Island’s Hard Water and Coastal Conditions

    Long Island

    Blake Ruwali

    Blake Ruwali

    EPA 608-Certified HVAC Technician

    Was this section helpful?

    Pros

    • A.O. Smith family quality
    • Very affordable
    • Basic reliable heating
    • Widely available

    Cons

    • Tank only
    • Basic features
    • Shorter warranty
    • No premium options

    American Water Heaters Key Specifications

    UEF Range

    0.65–0.7

    Price (Installed)

    $500–$1,500

    Tank Warranty

    6 years

    Types Available

    1

    American Water Heaters Water Heater Models We Install

    Detailed specs and pricing for American Water Heaters models available for Nassau County installation.

    ★ Top Pick
    Tank
    Value

    American ProLine 50-Gallon Natural Gas Water Heater

    Installed Price

    $900–$1,400

    Budget-friendly 50-gallon gas tank water heater for basic residential needs.

    UEF

    0.62

    1st Hr Rating

    80 gal

    Capacity

    50 gal

    BTU

    40k

    Pros

    • Affordable entry-level option
    • Widely available through contractors
    • Simple installation

    Cons

    • Lower UEF than competitors
    • Basic feature set
    • Shorter warranty
    Tank: 6 yearsParts: 6 yearsBest for: Budget-conscious homeownersView Details
    Tank
    Mid-range

    American ProLine XE High-Efficiency 50-Gallon Gas

    Installed Price

    $1,200–$1,800

    Mid-range gas tank with improved efficiency and longer warranty coverage.

    UEF

    0.7

    1st Hr Rating

    87 gal

    Capacity

    50 gal

    BTU

    50k

    Pros

    • Higher efficiency than standard
    • Better first-hour rating
    • Longer warranty

    Cons

    • Still uses atmospheric venting
    • Not Energy Star certified
    Tank: 8 yearsParts: 8 yearsBest for: Homeowners wanting better efficiency on a budgetView Details
    Was this section helpful?

    American Water Heaters Warranty Coverage

    Tank

    6 years

    Parts

    6 years

    Labor

    Varies

    Warranty terms require professional installation and product registration. We handle all warranty registration for our customers.

    Was this section helpful?

    American Water Heaters Water Heater Cost in 2026

    A American Water Heaters water heater costs $500–$1,500 installed on Long Island, depending on the fuel type, capacity, venting, and code-required upgrades. That range covers the equipment, standard installation labor, and haul-away of the old unit — exact pricing is confirmed in writing after a short in-home assessment.

    American Water Heaters Installed Range

    $500–$1,500

    Value tier ($) • 6 years tank warranty

    What moves the price:

    • Fuel type and capacity (tank vs. tankless vs. heat pump)
    • Venting, gas-line, or electrical upgrades required by code
    • Expansion tank and haul-away scope
    • Heat pump models may qualify for PSEG-LI instant rebates

    Prices reflect typical Nassau County installations including labor and materials. Federal 25C ended after 2025; current heat pump water-heater incentives vary by model and program.

    American Water Heaters Water Heater Cost by Size (40, 50 & 75 Gallon)

    A standard 40-gallon tank replacement starts at $3,700 installed on Long Island, a 50-gallon tank from $4,100, and a 75-gallon tank from $5,900. Capacity is only part of the answer — the first-hour rating, fuel type, venting and code-required upgrades decide the final written price.

    Size / type Fits Installed
    40-gallon gas tank 1–3 people, 1–2 bathsBaseline like-for-like replacement including haul-away From $3,700
    50-gallon gas tank 3–4 people, 2 bathsMost common upsize when the old 40 ran short on back-to-back showers From $4,100
    75-gallon gas tank 5+ people, 3+ baths or a soaking tubOften needs venting and gas-line review before it can be approved From $5,900
    50-gallon electric tank 3–4 people, no gas serviceElectrical circuit and breaker capacity confirmed on site From $3,400
    Heat pump water heater Basement or utility-space installsPSEG-LI instant rebate of $1,000–$1,200 applies to qualifying models From $4,900
    Tankless (gas) Continuous hot water, space savingsConversion project: venting, gas capacity, condensate and water quality From $6,500

    What size water heater do I need?

    • Match the first-hour rating to your busiest hour, not just the gallon number on the label
    • Add capacity if showers run back-to-back or a soaking tub is in use
    • Tankless is sized by peak flow and incoming water temperature, not gallons
    • Heat pump models need clearance and air volume around the unit
    Was this section helpful?

    American Water Heaters Brand History

    1874
    Now

    Founded in 1874

    American Water Heaters has been manufacturing water heaters for over 152 years. Proudly American-made.

    Part of A.O. Smith Corporation

    A.O. Smith Corporation also manufactures A.O. Smith, State Water Heaters, Lochinvar — sharing engineering and manufacturing platforms.

    How American Water Heaters Compares

    Metric American Water Heaters Lochinvar Vaughn
    Rating 3.8/5 4.2/5 4.1/5
    Price (Installed) $500–$1,500 $1,500–$5,500 $1,500–$4,000
    UEF (Max) 0.7 0.96 0.99
    Tank Warranty 6 years 10 years Lifetime
    Tier value premium premium

    Who Should Choose American Water Heaters?

    Large Families

    American Water Heaters tank models deliver high first-hour ratings for back-to-back showers.

    Small Homes

    American Water Heaters's smaller tank models fit tight utility closets in older Long Island homes.

    Energy Savings

    American Water Heaters's high-efficiency models help cut energy bills with UEF ratings up to 0.7.

    American Water Heaters FAQs

    Ready for a American Water Heaters Water Heater?

    Get a free, no-pressure quote from our certified technicians who install American Water Heaters water heaters regularly.

    Get a American Water Heaters Quote

    3.8/5Expert Rating
    Price Range:$500–$1,500
    Tank Warranty:6 years
    Max UEF:0.7
    Types:1
    Insured & EPA-Certified Installers

    Free estimates • Same-day service available

    Long Island

    The brand matters less than the installer

    A great water heater installer on Long Island will outperform a premium unit installed poorly. Use the verification checklist and three-estimate worksheet before you sign anything.

    Open the contractor comparison guide

    American Water Heaters Heater Types

    Tank

    Related A.O. Smith Corporation Brands

    🔥 Water Heater Buying Guide

    Tank vs tankless vs heat pump — find the right water heater for your Nassau County home.

    Read the Guide →

    About This Review

    Amy Milani

    Amy Milani

    Writer

    Blake Ruwali

    Blake Ruwali

    EPA 608-Certified Reviewer

    Updated:

    Use ← → arrow keys to navigate between brands